大学物理 ›› 2026, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (2): 55-.doi: 10.16854/j.cnki.1000-0712.250099

• 物理学史与物理学家 • 上一篇    下一篇

回看二十世纪量子物理学史中的爱因斯坦 纪念爱因斯坦逝世70周年、狄拉克逝世40周年、 希尔伯特逝世80周年(二)和希尔伯特的竞争—从泊松方程到引力场方程

赵松年, 于允贤, 王川   

  1. 1. 中国科学院 大气物理研究所,北京100029;2. 国家地震局 减灾中心,北京100029;3. 北京师范大学 人工智能学院,北京100875
  • 收稿日期:2025-02-27 修回日期:2025-03-28 出版日期:2026-05-15 发布日期:2026-05-21
  • 作者简介:赵松年(1939—2025),男,天津市人,中国科学院大气物理研究所研究员,主要从事大气湍流探测和信息处理.
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金委(62071448)资助.

Einstein in the history of quantum physics in the 20th century#br# (2) Competition with Hilbert—from Poisson equations to gravitational field equations#br#

  1. 1. Institute of Atmospheric Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100029, China; 
    2. Disaster Reduction Center, China Earthquake Administration, Beijing 100029, China; 
    3. School of Artificial Intelligence, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China
  • Received:2025-02-27 Revised:2025-03-28 Online:2026-05-15 Published:2026-05-21

摘要: 本文探讨物理学史中一个令人困惑的问题,就是爱因斯坦几乎苦苦探索近八年之久的引力场方程,希尔伯特却在聆听了爱因斯坦的6次相关报告之后,就能在建立引力场方程的竞争中,几乎同时到达终点,这中间自然存在从物理学思索引力问题和从数学思索引力问题的不同,或者说,物理学家和数学家对待和处理引力问题的方式以及着眼点不同.他们二人各自对泊松方程的深入思考与分析,从中获得了重要的启发,由此确立了各自建立引力场方程的正确思路.但是,如果深入思考,就会很自然地提出是否存在其他的学术观点和探索思路,妨碍爱因斯坦顺利地思考引力问题?无疑,这是一个科学界的值得深思与探讨的问题.为了比较,本文给出了爱因斯坦从物理概念和希尔伯特从变分学推导引力场方程的全过程,内容简单易懂;涉及到张量这一数学工具,文中对此给出了简单、明了、概念清晰的论述。为了提高可读性,文中附有作者绘制的从矢量到张量的新颖图示,相信读者朋友读过此文,必定会对广义相对论的引力场方程、变分学方法和张量与矢量的关系有更深入的理解;对爱因斯坦和希尔伯特两位著名科学家不同的研究风格和创造模式也会有所领悟.


关键词: 引力场, 度规张量, 黎曼弯曲空间, 闵可夫斯基时空, 最小作用原理

Abstract:  This article discusses a puzzling problem in the history of physics, that is, Einstein almost struggled to explore the gravitational field equation for nearly eight years, but Hilbert was able to reach the end of the race to establish the gravitational field equation almost simultaneously after listening to Einstein’s six relevant reports. Naturally, there is a difference between thinking about gravity in physics and thinking about gravity in mathematics, or in the way physicists and mathematicians approach and deal with gravity. Their deep thinking and analysis of Poisson's equation obtained important inspiration from it, and thus established the correct idea of establishing their own gravitational field equation. However, if one thinks deeply, it is natural to ask whether there are other academic viewpoints and lines of inquiry that prevent Einstein from thinking smoothly about gravity. Undoubtedly, this is a scientific community worthy of deep thought and discussion. In order to compare, this paper gives the whole process of deriving the equations of gravitational field from the physical concept of Einstein and from the variational theory of Hilbert. When it comes to tensor, a mathematical tool, the paper gives a simple, clear and conceptual discussion. In order to improve readability, the novel diagram from vector to tensor drawn by the author is attached. The author believes that readers who have read this article will certainly have a deeper understanding of the gravitational field equation of general relativity, the variational method and the relationship between tensor and vector; You will also gain insight into the different research styles and creative modes of two famous scientists, Einstein and Hilbert.

Key words: gravitational field, metric tensor, Riemann curved space, Minkowski space-time, principle of least action